Payment & Ordering

  • Whenever possible, we like to have at least 2 months notice (more if possible) for wedding cake orders.
  • We accept cash, check, credit card, Venmo, Zelle, Cash App, Apple Pay, and PayPal.
  • A 50% deposit is due when you place your order in order to secure your date on the calendar. The final payment is due when you pick up your cake. (For weddings, $100 deposit puts you on the calendar and the final payment is due 1 month before the wedding.)
  • When possible, we will accept last minute orders (within 1 week of the pickup/delivery date) and charge a “rush baking” fee of $5 more per 1 dozen of cupcakes and $25 more per cake. Orders of these types will be accepted or denied at our discretion.
  • Tax is 8%.


Cake Pricing

The following estimated prices are for celebration and birthday cakes only. Please contact us for wedding cake information and pricing.

  • 1 TIER CAKES – start around $3.00 per serving.
  • 2 TIER (OR MORE) CAKES – start at $3.50 per serving.
  • 3D CAKES – start at $150.00.

* NOTE: Listed prices are baseline/starting prices for cakes. Final prices account for number of tiers, number of servings, flavors of cake, complexity of the design requested, etc.

The Cakehole does not do sheet cakes.


Cupcake Pricing

  • The price of cupcakes is $2.00 each. This does NOT include decorated cupcakes. Decorated, specialty cupcakes START at $3.00 each.
  • In the shop, we have a variety of flavors available every day that we are open. If you pick from our available flavors, you can get 6 cupcakes for the price of 5 ($10 before tax) or 12 cupcakes for the price of 10 ($20 before tax).

Delivery/Delivery Fees

  • Custom (non-wedding) celebration cake delivery within 15 miles starts at $50.00.
  • Wedding cake delivery within 15 miles starts at $100.00.
  • Delivery always includes assembly of the cake.
  • Fees for delivery will be added to the final cost of the wedding cake. Deliveries beyond the Indianapolis area are determined based on round trip mileage.